This guide aims to differentiate between various types of bot management solutions, from basic protection to advanced threat mitigation. As bot attacks evolve in sophistication, organisations must understand the capabilities and limitations of different bot management approaches.
The Need for Bot Management
Bots pose a range of threats to online platforms:
- Content scraping by large language models
- Competitive intelligence gathering
- Price scraping
- Inventory hoarding
- Credential stuffing attacks
- Account takeovers
These threats can lead to:
- Intellectual property theft
- Increased server costs
- Skewed analytics
- Loss of competitive advantage
- Financial losses
- Reputational damage
For more information on the business impact of these threats, read our article on the Business Impact of Credential Stuffing.
Classes of Bot Management
Bot management solutions fall into three main categories: basic, intermediate, and advanced. Each level builds upon the capabilities of the previous one.
Basic Protection
Basic bot management targets well-behaved bots and provides a foundation for bot detection.
Methods include:
- User agent checks
- IP reputation databases
- Simple rate limiting
Capabilities:
- Blocks known bot signatures
- Prevents excessive requests from single sources
- Identifies and manages well-behaved web crawlers
Limitations:
- Fails against bots that mimic browsers
- Cannot detect distributed attacks
- Lacks protection against sophisticated threats
Intermediate Protection
Intermediate protection builds on basic methods to combat general site scraping and non-persistent threats.
Additional methods:
- JavaScript-based detections
- Header analysis
- Basic network fingerprinting (e.g., JA3/JA4 fingerprinting)
Capabilities:
- Detects bots that can't execute JavaScript
- Identifies inconsistencies in request headers
- Recognises patterns in connection establishments
Limitations:
- Struggles with highly sophisticated bots and residential proxies
- Limited protection against distributed attacks
- Lacks comprehensive API protection
Advanced Protection
Advanced bot management provides comprehensive protection against persistent, sophisticated threats, including credential stuffing and account takeover attempts.
Additional methods:
- Comprehensive network fingerprinting
- Advanced rate limiting
- API endpoint awareness
- Traffic class inspection
- Real-time threat mitigation
- Residential proxy detection
- Integration with WAF/WAAP data, including breached credential scanning
Capabilities:
- Detects and mitigates sophisticated, human-like bots
- Protects against distributed attacks using residential proxies
- Offers granular control and real-time response
- Provides comprehensive protection for websites, APIs, and mobile apps
- Utilises breached credential data to inform defence strategies
Advanced solutions terminate connections directly, rather than passing traffic through intermediary services like CDNs.
For a deeper dive into advanced bot protection techniques, read our article on Enhancing Defences Against Layer 7 DDoS Attacks.
Choosing the Right Level of Protection
The appropriate level of bot management depends on an organisation's specific needs and threat landscape:
- Basic protection suits organisations facing minimal bot threats or those primarily dealing with well-behaved bots.
- Intermediate protection benefits organisations experiencing general scraping attempts and non-persistent threats.
- Advanced protection proves essential for organisations facing sophisticated, persistent threats or those in high-risk industries like e-commerce, finance, or gaming.
As bot attacks continue to evolve, many organisations find that basic or intermediate protection no longer suffices. Advanced bot management offers the comprehensive defence needed to safeguard digital assets, maintain user trust, and ensure business continuity in the face of increasingly sophisticated bot threats.
For organisations looking to assess their current bot protection needs, Peakhour offers a Bot Security Check service.
Peakhour's Bot Management Solution
Peakhour's Bot Management solution provides advanced protection against sophisticated bot threats. It combines multiple detection techniques, including:
Our solution also integrates with other Peakhour services such as WAF, API Security, and Account Protection to provide a comprehensive security posture.
By understanding the different levels of bot management, organisations can make informed decisions about their security needs and invest in solutions that provide appropriate protection against the bot threats they face.
